| |
WSPE eNews
A monthly publication from the Wisconsin Society of Professional
Engineers
January 2009 Edition
1. |
WSPE's President's Corner |
Fellow P.E.s,
2008 was a year that I will long remember. I am amazed at the amount
of snow we have been getting. I think we were spoiled for a number
of years, and it looks like the weather gods are in the payback
mode. Of course, having spent my undergraduate time at Michigan
Tech during a record snowfall year, this isn’t much of anything.
If it gets so bad that I have to enter my house through the second
floor window, as they do in some places in Michigan’s U.P.,
it will be time to worry. If it wasn’t for the negative environmental
impacts, global warming may not be a bad deal.
If it isn’t the weather it is the economy. And, of course,
to a lesser degree, if you are a football fan, there is the downfall
of the Packers and Badgers. It has been a tough year in the Wisconsin
football scene.
Even amidst all the turmoil and negativity in 2008, there are no
doubt much worse problems. Let’s be thankful for the good
things and try to maintain a positive outlook as we move into 2009.
As a reminder, the 2009 WSPE Discovery Conference and Governor’s
New Product Award dinner are scheduled for Thursday, April 23, 2009
in Green Bay. The Discovery Conference will focus on topics relating
to the “Future of Energy.” While the final list of speakers
and topics is still in development, we have several potential speakers
from Wisconsin’s Office of Energy Independence, Great Lakes
Bioenergy Research Center, Electric Power Research Institute, and
Wisconsin Public Service Corporation. We hope to finalize the program
by mid-January. We still have room on the program for additional
speakers. Topics that would be of particular interest would be in
the areas of solar energy, fuel cell technology, coal, oil, and
geothermal energy. Please give me a call or e-mail me (Michael.Lefebvre@gasai.com)
if you have any ideas. The GNPA dinner will be held at Lambeau Field.
In addition to outstanding technical sessions, the venue will be
exceptional. Please put this conference and GNPA dinner on your
2009 schedule.
One last note….we are in need of an individual to fill the
vacant spot of Young Engineer Representative on the WSPE State Board.
If you know of someone or feel that you would like to be that person,
give me a call or e-mail me. It is a great opportunity to get involved
with WSPE on a State level and work with some great professionals.
Have a great holiday season and a super 2009.
Michael J. Lefebvre, P.E.
TOP |
SPONSOR

College of Engineering
Master of Engineering Professional Practice
A world-class graduate degree
to advance your career as a technical leader, featuring:
- Tools and strategies for succeeding in the global engineering
marketplace
- Unique blend of technical and managerial knowledge and skills
to help you advance as a leader
- Internet-based, collaborative learning with no interruption
to career or travel
Only 30 students admitted each
year - reserve your spot today!
|
2. |
2009 Engineers Week Resources - Feb. 15-21, 2009 |
| Engineers Week (E-Week) occurs from February 15-21,
2009, and it is a great time for engineers to get out to local schools
and teach children of all ages about the exciting opportunities
available in engineering and related fields. WSPE has access to
information on a wide variety of classroom activities and presentations
to help make it easy for our members to reach out to schools and
encourage more kids to pursue careers in engineering.
If you have never done anything like this before, you will be amazed
at how easy and rewarding it is! Kids are very curious, but many
of them have no idea what kinds of things engineers do or how critically
important our work is. By doing a presentation that explains the
different types of engineering or by working with kids on classroom
activities, you can open up a whole new world of possibilities.
The participating kids benefit from the adventure, and they tell
their friends about it, so the learning and excitement at Engineers
Week has a ripple effect among children.
Please consider taking a little time around E-Week to contact a
school and arrange a time to do a presentation or activity. Contact
Chad O'Donnell, P.E., at 414-278-3347 or codonnell@hga.com
for more information. Thank you for your support of the engineering
profession!
NSPE Partners with “Design Squad”
The National Society of Professional Engineers (NSPE) has partnered
with “Design Squad” a 30-minute television program that
airs nationally on PBS to encourage its members to promote the engineering
profession to future generations. The “Design
Squad” Web site contains a wealth of resources for engineers
to use to help young people experience engineering first-hand. The
activities found on the Engineers
page can be easily duplicated for in-school presentations. The
site also includes a profiles and video library of copyright-free
videos that could be used to highlight different aspects of the
profession.
We encourage you to use these resources and visit a local school
during National Engineers Week (February 15-21, 2009).
For more information about the “Design Squad” program
please click
here.
TOP |
3. |
Entries Encouraged for WSPE’s 2009
Governor’s New Product Awards Competition |
| You are invited to enter the Wisconsin Society of
Professional Engineers (WSPE) 2009 Governor’s New Product
Awards (GNPA) Competition. Applications are due February 16, 2009.
The awards ceremony and banquet will be held Thursday evening, April
23, 2009 inside Lambeau Field’s Legends Club Room, Green Bay,
WI. For applications, click
here.
The 2009 GNPA winners will be entered into NSPE’s (National
Society of Professional Engineers) 2010 new product competition.
Last year, two companies from WI (InSinkerator and Cummins) won
at NSPE’s 2008 competition.
For additional information, please contact Dale R. Swenson, P.E.,
WSPE Chair, 414-343-8452, dale.swenson@harley-davidson.com.
TOP |
| SPONSOR
Continue your education at home or on the road.
UW-Platteville’s award-winning, accredited online degree programs
save you time and money and provide the quality that you expect.
- Increase your professional experience and value
- Network with professionals from across the nation
- “Go to class” at times that work for you
- No campus visits are required
Inquire today about our online Master of Science
in Engineering or Master of Science in Project Management!
800.362-5460 · 608.342.1468
· DistanceEd@uwplatt.edu
|
4. |
College of Engineering, Math and Science (EMS)
Expo April 2, 2009 |
Mark your calendars! This expo has two purposes:
to inform youth what engineering, mathematics and science are all
about, and to provide incentive for the challenge awaiting those
of you who choose a career in one of these fields. You will have
the opportunity to observe students and faculty “in action”
and to see what people educated at UW-Platteville College of Engineering,
Mathematics and Science can do.
Look for more information soon at: http://www.uwplatt.edu/EXPO.
TOP |
| SPONSOR
|
5. |
The Effects of § 895.447, Wis.
Stats., Voiding Certain Agreements that Limit or Eliminate Tort
Liability Upon Indemnity Agreements in Standard Design Contracts
By Attorney Robert J. Kay |
In the last issue of this publication I discussed
the indemnity agreements that are found in standard design contracts.
In that article I discussed the indemnification provisions found
in AIA Document A201 - 2007, § 3.18 and EJCDC C-700 - 2007,
§ 6.20. Those indemnity provisions in standard design contracts
must be evaluated along with § 895.447 of the Wisconsin Statutes
which provides:
895.447 Certain agreements to limit or eliminate tort
liability void.
(1) Any provision to limit or eliminate tort liability as a part
of or in connection with any contract, covenant or agreement relating
to the construction, alteration, repair or maintenance of a building,
structure, or other work related to construction, including any
moving, demolition or excavation, is against public policy and
void.
(2) This section does not apply to any insurance contract or worker’s
compensation plan.
(3) This section shall not apply to any provision of any contract,
covenant or agreement entered into prior to July 1, 1978.
The Wisconsin Court of Appeals has addressed the issue of whether
§ 895.447, Wis. Stats., voided indemnity agreements contained
in construction contracts for a project. In Gerdmann v. U.S. Fire
Insurance Company, 119 Wis. 2d 367, 350 N.W.2d 730 (Ct. App. 1984),
the Wisconsin Court of Appeals held that § 895.49, Wis. Stats.
(renumbered § 895.447 by 2005 Act 155, § 49, effective
April 5, 2006) did not void indemnity agreements contained in construction
contracts. The Court held that indemnity clauses were not mentioned
in the statute and that it would be unreasonable to conclude that
the legislature intended to apply the statute to indemnity agreements.
The effect of the decision was to permit owners and contractors
on a construction project to enter into construction agreements
that contained indemnity provisions notwithstanding § 895.447,
Wis. Stats.
In the Gerdmann case, Gerdmann, an employee of Bay Shipbuilding,
was injured when he was accidentally struck by a wooden pole when
a Roen Salvage Company truck flipped the pole along a haul road
on property owned by the Manitowoc Company, Inc. Roen and its insurance
carrier settled with Gerdmann for $3,000,000 and Roen brought an
action against Manitowoc claiming that Manitowoc had violated the
Safe Place Statute by laying the poles near the haul road. The jury
found in favor of Manitowoc and the circuit court entered judgment
in favor of Manitowoc and against Roen because Manitowoc had counterclaimed
for indemnification. The construction contract between Manitowoc
and Roen stated:
Contractor shall indemnify the Owner and Engineer against and
hold the Owner and Engineer harmless from any and all liability
for damages on account of injury, including death, to persons,
including employees of Contractor, or damage to property resulting
from or arising out of or in any way connected with the performance
of work under this Contract by Contractor or any Subcontractor.
In addition, Contractor shall reimburse Owner for all costs, expenses,
and loss incurred by them in consequence of any claims, demands,
and causes of action, whether meritorious or not, which may be
brought against them and arising out of the operations covered
by the Contract . . . . Contractor shall pay any costs, including
Attorney’s fees, that may be incurred by Owner in enforcing
this indemnity . . . .
The Court of Appeals in Gerdmann was willing to apply
the indemnity agreement to Roen’s action for contribution
against Manitowoc. The Court stated:
Roen claims that the plain meaning of the clause’s language
shows that the clause does not apply when the parties to the agreement
are adverse. Both parties contend that the language of the agreement
is clear, and the trial court’s decision was based only
upon the language of the written agreement . . . .
The plain language of the clause is unambiguous. Roen argues
that the use of the word ‘them’ in the clause refers
to both Roen and Manitowoc, and that the clause only covers actions
brought against both. The clause, however, requires Roen to reimburse
‘Owner for all costs . . . incurred by them.’ . .
.
The indemnity clause provides for reimbursement of costs and
fees Manitowoc incurs ‘in consequence of any claims, demands,
and causes of action . . . which may be brought against them and
arising out of the operations covered by the Contract.’
The clause does not distinguish between claims brought by third
parties and actions brought for contribution. It covers ‘any
claims’ arising from the dredging operations, which includes
an action for contribution.
The Court of Appeals in Gerdmann noted that the Wisconsin
Supreme Court in Dykstra v. Arthur G. McKee, decided in
1981, noted that § 895.49 does not necessarily outlaw indemnity
agreements of this type, although the court in Dykstra
did not have to decide that question because the statute was not
in effect when the Dykstra indemnity agreement was made. Nonetheless,
the Gerdmann court noted that Supreme Court’s observation
was important. The Gerdmann court stated:
This indemnity agreement neither limits nor eliminates Manitowoc’s
tort liability to third parties. Rather, it makes Roen the insurer
should damages result. The Dykstra footnote indicates
that the supreme court did not believe that the statute clearly
voids such indemnity agreements, and since the statute must be
interpreted as narrowly as possible, we will not extend its coverage
to void this indemnity agreement.
The Gerdmann decision demonstrates that the indemnity agreements
found in construction contracts protecting owners and design professionals
is alive and well, notwithstanding § 895.447 of the Wisconsin
Statutes.
Attorney Robert J. Kay is the senior partner in the law firm
of Kay & Andersen, S.C. and devotes his time to representing professional
engineers, architects, contractors, material suppliers and owners
of construction projects. Please feel free to contact him at (608)
833-0077 or visit www.kayandandersen.com.
TOP |
6. |
Welcome New WSPE Members |
The WSPE board of directors would like to extend
a heartfelt welcome to the following new WSPE members:
- Dale B. Lindemer
National Engineering Manager
ThyssenKrupp Safway, Inc.
Southeast Chapter
New members contribute to the growth, strength and leadership of
the WSPE in enhancing its recognition as a leading voice for Professional
Engineers throughout Wisconsin and promoting excellence in engineering.
TOP |
|